Top 10 Website Mistakes That Make Donors Leave (and How to Fix Them)
Is your nonprofit website unintentionally turning donors away? Here are 10 simple but powerful fixes you can make right now.
Your cause deserves attention. But sometimes, the website that represents your social impact mission quietly pushes visitors away.
These small oversights can cost donations! Not because people don’t care, but because the experience makes it hard to act.
Hidden or Confusing Donate Button
If your donate button isn’t clear, large, and visible on every page, donors might never find it.
✅ Fix: Use a bold contrasting button in the top navigation with a clear label: “Donate Now.”
Overwhelming Homepage
Too much text or too many calls to action can confuse visitors.
✅ Fix: Simplify. Make your main goal (donation, volunteering, or subscription) instantly obvious.
Unclear Storytelling
Data is powerful, but emotion drives action.
✅ Fix: Add real stories, images, and quotes that show impact.
Slow Load Times
Every second counts.
✅ Fix: Compress large images and use a speed test tool to identify issues.
Not Mobile-Friendly
More than half of web traffic is mobile.
✅ Fix: Test your website on your phone. Ensure the donate button, menu, and contact form all work smoothly.
Weak Calls to Action
Generic phrases like “learn more” rarely convert.
✅ Fix: Use direct action phrases: “Help a family today,” “Sponsor a caregiver visit.”
Outdated Design
Visual trust matters.
✅ Fix: Use modern fonts, consistent branding, and fresh imagery.
Missing Impact Proof
Donors want to see results.
✅ Fix: Add short success stories or a “Your Impact” page.
Cluttered Navigation
Too many menu options overwhelm visitors.
✅ Fix: Stick to 5–7 top-level pages.
No SEO Basics
If you can’t be found, you can’t be funded.
✅ Fix: Add meta titles, descriptions, and alt text.
Want a professional review of your website with a clear action plan?
Order a Nonprofit Website Audit and receive your personalized report in 72 hours.
Ready to take your nonprofit to the next level? Explore more tips, tools, and resources at NonprofitToolkits and start making an even greater impact today!